Deciding how to organize a move can be challenging for many people. You might hear tall tales from friends about moving the contents of five rooms in a single sedan, listen to others rave about the money they saved using a professional moving company, or face offers of help from parents (with Dad insisting he knows exactly how to mount the bathroom shelves). All of this is likely to double, or even triple, your stress levels. In this article, we examine the key differences between a “full-service move” and a DIY move within the same city, as well as the options that fall somewhere in between. The final choice depends on your budget, the time you have available, and your (and your friends') willingness to handle the physical labor. Below, we outline the main advantages, disadvantages, and estimated costs for each option.
‍
Self-Service Moving (DIY)
This approach means you handle absolutely everything. You rent the truck, find the boxes, pack your items, move the furniture, and drive the vehicle yourself. Sometimes it involves coordinating with different friends to see who can transport your larger plants or haul away kitchen boxes in their cars.
The main benefit of this choice is saving money. You also maintain complete control over the process and know exactly where every important document is located.
The downside is the heavy physical labor and the hidden expenses. Renting a truck might look inexpensive, but the base rate always requires extra payments for mileage, fuel, and insurance. Plus, if you scratch a wall or drop a television, you bear the full financial responsibility because you are figuring out how to protect furniture during diy moving without professional training.
‍
Full cost breakdown of the move
To show what this actually looks like in practice, we want to share a story from a friend of our company. He recently moved from a two-bedroom apartment on W 2nd Ave in Kitsilano to Homer Street in Yaletown, and he shared his experience and receipts with us.
Our hero and three of his friends handled the heavy lifting. He rented a 15-foot U-Haul truck for the day. Packing his belongings required 40 boxes.
Inventory list:
- big IKEA wardrobe,
- solid-wood six-drawer dresser,
- three-seater sectional sofa,
- king-size bed frame with a heavy mattress,
- home exercise bike
- dining table.
People often think renting the truck means half the work is done. The actual cost breakdown proves there is much more to it. We verified his numbers, and here is exactly what he spent on his Vancouver move:
- Packing materials
Purchasing 40 medium cardboard boxes, 3 rolls of heavy-duty packing tape, a 3x30-foot roll of bubble wrap, and three moving blankets from Home Depot cost him $312.88 including taxes. The dolly was borrowed from the neighbors for free, and the tools were found at home. - Elevator booking fees
Most apartment buildings charge a non-refundable fee for elevator use and booking. The move took place on a Wednesday during the permitted daytime hours of 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM. Elevator services were booked two weeks in advance: a three-hour slot (8:00–11:00 AM) in Yaletown cost $150, and a four-hour slot (12:00–4:00 PM) in Kitsilano cost $200. A refundable deposit of $200 was also required in both instances (though everything went without any damages, and the deposits were returned). The total cost for the elevator services was $350. - Truck rental and insurance
The base rate for his 15-foot U-Haul was $29.95. He drove about 20 kilometers total (including picking up and dropping off the truck), which added $21.80 at a rate of $1.09/km. He also paid $21 for Damage Coverage (Safemove+Collision Damage Waiver) and a $1 environmental fee. With taxes, the final rental receipt came to $77.47. - Fuel
A loaded 15-foot truck is heavy and gets roughly 25 liters per 100 kilometers. Driving 20 kilometers burned about 5 liters of gas. At $1.90 per liter, fuel added $10. - Pizza and drinks for four people - $75.14 (including taxes).
Total financial cost $825.49 (including taxes).
While spending around $800 might be cheaper than hiring professionals, non-financial costs were much higher. Before loading anything, disassembling his double bed and the IKEA wardrobe took an hour and a half. Reassembling them late that night, when everyone was tired, took another two and a half hours.
Then came the property damage. To save on supplies, he only bought three moving blankets and wrapped the rest of his furniture in his personal winter blankets. While carrying his solid-wood dresser down a narrow hallway, a winter blanket slipped off.
The result was a ruined winter blanket and a chip on the edge of a two-year-old dresser that was previously in perfect condition. Because it was not professionally packed and secured, the responsibility for the damage rested entirely on his shoulders.
Ultimately, his DIY move required 10 hours of hard labor and resulted in damaged furniture. It is a high price to pay just to save a bit of money.
‍
Full-Service Moving
The full-service option means a professional crew handles the entire cycle. They come to your place on a scheduled day and time. Movers lay down floor runners, cover stair railings and entry doors with blankets to protect from scratches while they carry out big furniture pieces. Disassemble beds and any furniture that requires it, carefully wrap all parts, other fragile items, mirrors, and pictures in moving blankets. Pack and label all boxes and bins. Load the truck and transport everything. After all furniture is assembled back room by room, they assist with moving and arranging it if needed. They also unpack all the boxes and place items exactly as they were in the previous location. Collect all garbage after unpacking, and if you need, they also can take your old or broken furniture and take it to the closest landfill, or donation center for you. All these steps from start to finish are covered by a full service moving company.
The main advantages of this option are the time you save and the safety of your belongings, which are even insured. Professional packers and movers take responsibility for every item. You won't have to carry heavy sofas or figure out how to pack and move heavy appliances yourself.
The main disadvantage of this format is the price, which exceeds the cost of renting a truck yourself.
To show what this looks like in practice, here's an example of a recent move in Vancouver from our team:
‍
Logistics and property inventory
Our client needed to move from a two-bedroom apartment (approximately 980 sq ft) on Homer Street to a new two-bedroom apartment on Marinaside Crescent in Vancouver. The distance between the objects was only 1 km, but the volume of things was impressive.
Inventory list:
‍Not including books, decor, rugs and small fragile items from drawers.
- 2 beds
- 1 couch
- 1 desk
- portable sauna < 200 lbs
- bookcase
- TV stand
- 80 inch TV
- coffee table
- 2 dressers
- 2 end tables
- + all items from the storage unit in the underground
‍
Three-day work plan
The client ordered a comprehensive package of services including packing, transportation and unpacking. To keep the process organized, the project was divided into three days. Before work even began, coordinators confirmed elevator reservation times and fulfilled the customer's morning Starbucks order to get the first day off to a good start.
Day 1: Packing
Two professional packers arrived to carry out all the preparatory work. They dismantled the beds and desk, wrapped all furniture and fragile items in protective blankets, and packed small items into boxes. Before packing the 80-inch TV, they checked its functionality and took pictures of the screen. Finally, they cleared the hallways to allow easy access for the moving crew the next morning.
Day 2: Transportation
A team of two movers on a 26-foot (about 8 meters) truck called 30 minutes before arrival. They immediately covered the floor with floor runners to keep the apartment clean and prevent scratches. All belongings were loaded into the elevator, carefully transported the short distance to Marinaside Crescent and carefully unloaded at the new home.
Day 3: Unpacking
One of the packers returned to unpack boxes, assemble furniture, and help arrange heavy items exactly where the customer wanted them. Upon completion of the work, we removed all trash, including empty boxes, packaging paper and stretch film. The apartment remained perfectly clean. In addition, the client was given a small housewarming gift from Cactus Moving.
‍
‍Total cost of services
Professional services are always more expensive than renting a truck yourself, but they completely relieve the client of physical labor and any responsibility.
Below is a detailed calculation of the cost of this project:
- Day 1: Packing (2 packers at $119/hour plus $99 one-time operations fee) - $1,169.18
- Day 2: Moving (2 movers and 26' truck for $169/hour plus $99 one-time operations fee) - $1,789.73
- Day 3: Unpacking (1 packer for $69/hour plus $99 one-time operations fee) - $466.20
The total cost: $3,425.11 including taxes.
Limited Service Moving (Hybrid Moving)
The limited service option is the perfect middle ground for many people. You take on small tasks that are convenient for you, and professional moving assistants can handle the heavy lifting and transport. This approach significantly reduces your final bill while saving your back. Here's how a recent hybrid move turned out for one of our Vancouver clients.
‍
Route and inventory
Our client was moving from a terraced house on Dumfries Street to a 2 bedroom apartment on Knight Street. The distance was short: only 2.7 km, which took about 15 minutes in local traffic.
Inventory list:
- 1 queen bed in box
- 1 single bed with mattress
- 1 bedside table
- 2 bookshelves
- 1 couch in box
- 1 seater sofa
- small treadmill
- 1 56" TV
- 1 standing lamp
- 1 dresser
- some nesting tables
- about 30 boxes
- no heavy lifts
‍
Scope of Work
To save money, the client decided to pack all his personal belongings himself. By the time the crew arrived, there were about 30 boxes taped up and ready to go at the customer’s door. They hired our team solely to protect the furniture, do the lifting and ensure safe delivery and drop-off. Our team brought the necessary tools and materials for the move. We wrapped the furniture in moving blankets, placed the mattress in a protective bag, and securely packed the large flat screen TV in a special, sturdy box (we always check TVs before we pack, and before we leave).
‍
Final Cost Breakdown
The proposed plan included two movers and a 26-foot truck at a rate of $179 per hour, plus a one-time operations fee of $99. We originally expected the project to take five to seven hours. Based on this estimate, the projected cost would be around approximately $1,253.
Because the client carefully packed and organized their boxes before the crew arrived, the loading process went faster. The team completed the entire move in exactly 5 hours and 15 minutes.
The final bill was $1,090.69 including all taxes.
This hybrid approach shows how preparing your own boxes can save you money while allowing professionals to do the difficult physical work.
‍
If you are relocating and need reliable professionals, Cactus Moving provides clear rates with no hidden fees. We execute residential relocations, office and commercial moving, and full service long distance moving across Canada. We offer a transparent moving quote, access to a moving company with storage, and targeted help with specific stages of your project.
‍
